What the cart actually claims to do differently
Smart carts have circulated in retail for years as a navigation and self-checkout convenience, with advertising bolted on as an afterthought. Hanshow's pitch with Merlin Smart Cart reverses that framing: the cart treats in-store media as part of the shopper service itself, linking product discovery, personalized offers, live basket visibility and checkout into one flow rather than treating the screen as an ad unit a shopper tolerates on the way to paying. That distinction decided the award. Philippe Brochard, Chairman of Hanshow's Advisory Committee, described the ambition as the cart becoming "a new interaction layer in the physical store," positioning it as infrastructure rather than a one-off gadget.
Whether that framing holds up under real store conditions is a separate question from whether it won an award, and the announcement does not yet answer it. Scott Thompson, RTIH's founder and editor, said the judges were drawn to the idea that in-store media "has moved beyond traditional channels" and, notably, "can also be measured," a comment that signals measurement was part of the pitch to judges even though no measurement data accompanies the public announcement. For a retail CTO, that gap between claim and public evidence is the first thing worth flagging before any procurement conversation starts.
Three vendors, one cart, one integration risk
Merlin Smart Cart is not a single company's product end to end. Hanshow provides the hardware and the in-store digital infrastructure it runs on. shopreme supplies the self-checkout software experience and the integration into a retailer's existing systems. Lucky cart adds the personalization engine and the retail media capability that monetizes the whole thing. That three-vendor structure is common in retail technology, where no single company owns hardware, checkout software and ad-tech personalization at once, but it also means any retailer adopting the cart is signing up for three vendor relationships and three sets of support and update cycles bundled into one purchasing decision.
The clip-on design is the practical mitigation for part of that risk. Because the hardware attaches to an existing trolley fleet rather than requiring a full replacement, a retailer can pilot or exit the technology without writing off a capital investment in new carts. That lowers the switching cost meaningfully, but it does not remove the deeper integration question: whether the software and personalization layers can plug cleanly into a retailer's existing loyalty data, point-of-sale systems and retail media operation, or whether they require building new data pipelines to make the measurement claims behind the award actually verifiable in a live store.
Reading an award win without a deployment to point to
The judging panel for the 2026 RTIH Innovation Awards included people from Walmart, Amazon, Boots, Ikea, Fabletics, Holland & Barrett, CVS Health and IGD, a credible group for assessing retail technology. But judging a product and deploying it are different acts, and none of those organizations is named as a Merlin Smart Cart customer. No retailer anywhere is named as a customer in the announcement, and no store count, pilot result or revenue figure accompanies the win. That makes this, at this stage, a credibility signal rather than a proof point: experienced judges found the concept compelling enough to award, which is worth something, but it is not evidence the product performs at scale in a working store.
Brochard's comment that Hanshow is working with ecosystem partners "while keeping the shopper experience at the centre" is the kind of statement every vendor makes about every product, and it carries no verification value on its own. For a retail CTO or retail media lead evaluating cart-based advertising technology, the right response to an award like this is to treat it as a shortlist entry rather than a reference case, and to ask directly for a retailer willing to speak about a live deployment before any procurement conversation moves further.
Why retail media infrastructure decisions deserve this scrutiny
Retail media has become one of the highest-margin lines in large retail businesses, which is exactly why vendors are racing to attach personalization and advertising capability to hardware shoppers already touch, carts, shelf edges, checkout screens. That race produces genuinely useful infrastructure, but it also produces award-season announcements optimized to generate inbound interest before the underlying product has a reference customer to show. A retail CTO's job is to separate the two without dismissing either, because the concept behind Merlin Smart Cart, monetizing the cart as a service layer rather than an ad unit, is a reasonable direction even without a named deployment yet.
The practical test for any retailer considering this category of technology is the same regardless of vendor: ask for the measurement methodology behind any lift or engagement claim before it is made publicly, confirm how the personalization layer handles existing loyalty and privacy commitments, and price the integration work across three vendors separately from the hardware cost, since that is where unplanned budget and timeline usually get lost. Merlin Smart Cart may prove itself in deployment. The award alone confirms only that it photographed well to a panel of experienced judges.
The data question behind personalization at the cart
Lucky cart's personalization layer presumably draws on some combination of loyalty identity, basket history or in-store location to tailor offers on the cart screen, which means the hardware has to connect to a retailer's existing customer data platform and consent framework to work as described. That is a materially different integration than the self-checkout and navigation features Hanshow and shopreme supply, because it involves identifiable or semi-identifiable customer data crossing between systems built and operated by three separate companies, each with its own data handling practices and its own incentive to retain whatever it collects.
Before signing on, any retailer in a regulated privacy market needs clear answers on exactly what data moves between the loyalty system and the three-vendor cart stack, who stores it, for how long, and under what consent basis the shopper agreed to it. In-store personalization built on identifiable customer data carries different regulatory weight than anonymous aggregate shelf analytics, and that distinction tends to get glossed over in award announcements focused on the shopper experience rather than the data architecture making that experience possible underneath.



